Category: Reviews

  • Exam Review: Cisco SCOR 350-701

    I have been putting off writing this review for a year and a half now.  I did finally pass the SCOR exam and earn my CCNP Security certification, but only after four attempts and more hours than I care to try and estimate.  Don’t get me wrong – this is the first time I’ve ever framed a certification and hung it in my cubicle because I remember vividly what I went through to attain it.  I’m very happy and proud to have passed, but it seriously burned me out on studying for exams.

    After I passed the SISE exam in July of 2020, I immediately began studying for the SCOR exam.  My first attempt at it was in late September.  The next three attempts were all in the month of October, with my final passing result coming on October 24th.

    A major problem I had was specifically due to the official Cisco course guide being very scattered and irrelevant to the exam material, as well as my own lack of hands-on experience with any of the technologies covered by the exam apart from Identity Services Engine.  I also had some experience in studying for the retired IINS exam which included ASAs and VPNs, but I still do not have any experience with ESAs, WSAs, Umbrella, FirePOWER, or any of the other solutions covered by the SCOR.

    The greatest asset I had during my SCOR studies was a study group that was arranged by Martin B.(@martinmbne / mbne.net) for several of us who were all pursuing the CCNP Security certification.  We all shared our study notes, white papers we’d found, our wins, our losses, and they were a constant source of inspiration and motivation for me.  I would be remiss if I didn’t also mention Carl Zellers (@cfzellers4) and Kim Pedersen (@kpjungle / packet-forwarding.net) for offering their support and commiserations as I worked through my many exam attempts.

    Score Results

    This exam frustrated me for many reasons. One of those reasons is how close I came to passing on my second and third attempts. I’ve included the exam results of all of my attempts below for transparency.

    Exam TopicAttempt #1Attempt #2Attempt #3Attempt #4
    Security Concepts 80% 76% 84% 88%
    Network Security 52% 67% 67% 81%
    Securing the Cloud 67% 73% 80% 100%
    Content Security 64% 64% 71% 79%
    Endpoint Protection & Detection 70% 70% 50% 70%
    Secure Network Access, Visibility & Enforcement 80% 87% 80% 87%

    Study Materials and Cost

    For preparation, I used the following resources:

    CCNP and CCIE Security Core SCOR 350-701 Official Cert Guide (Cisco Press) – Cost: $73.60
    The nicest thing that I have to say about this book is that it I highly recommend it, at least as a starting point. You need to understand up front that this book does not do an adequate job of covering the exam material in enough detail — and honestly, doesn’t cover some exam material at all. You will not pass the SCOR exam solely by reading this book. If anything, my personal opinion is that this book gets you less than half the way there.

    Implementing and Operating Cisco Security Core Technologies (SCOR) v1.0 (Cisco Learning Library) – Cost:  $500
    Just like with the SISE exam, I’ve listed the retail cost here, but since I used Cisco learning credits this resource ended up being free to me.  I would still recommend it if you can afford it – or have learning credits available for use.  It makes a good companion to the printed materials and includes practice questions which aren’t carbon copies of those found in the OCG practice test.

    CCNP and CCIE Security Core SCOR 350-701 Complete Video Course (Pearson LiveLessons) – Cost: $129.89
    This video series is given by the same person who authored the OCG book, Omar Santos. I went into this with high expectations of exam-relevant content. If I had to do it again…I’m not sure I would invest in this product. About the only useful thing I got out of it were the practice test questions.

    Integrated Security Technologies and Solutions – Volume I: Cisco Security Solutions for Advanced Threat Protection with Next Generation Firewall, Intrusion Prevention, AMP, and Content Security (Cisco Press) – Cost: $56.28
    Integrated Security Technologies and Solutions – Volume II: Cisco Security Solutions for Network Access Control, Segmentation, Context Sharing, Secure Connectivity and Virtualization (Cisco Press) – Cost: $56.28
    After my second exam attempt, I think it was, these two books were recommended to me as resources by members of my study group. These are great resources. Again, you will not pass the exam with only these books, but I highly recommend them as a supplement to the OCG.

    Network Security Technologies and Solutions (Cisco Press) – Cost: $91.68
    I found this book on my own simply by browsing through the Cisco Press catalog of publications. It was not recommended to me, and I don’t believe anyone else in the study group used it. If you can afford to add this to your studies then I do recommend purchasing it. That said, if I had to choose only between this and the two volumes listed above, I’d pick those two.

    Exam Fees – Cost: $1,600.00
    Pretty self-explanatory here. Each exam attempt was $300, and I took it four times before I passed.

    In Retrospect…

    I spent a long time cursing the name of Omar Santos after this exam. I recently saw his name as one of the listed authors on a Cisco Press book that I was thinking about buying and immediately decided against it.

    In hindsight, I don’t know what kind of situation this exam was developed under…the material was the worst of any Cisco exam I have ever taken, but how closely did Cisco work to ensure that the material accurately reflected the exam?

    I don’t know, and I shouldn’t take that all out on Omar. I don’t even know the guy.

    My pockets are a lot lighter now and I’m fairly positive that I gained several new grey hairs (probably also lost a few permanently) as a result of this exam. But like I said before…I feel a great sense of accomplishment now that I have this certification, and I have gotten a fair amount of recognition from people I work with for having attained it.

    What’s Next?

    To be frank, I’m not really sure. I did take (and fail) the ENWLSD exam last year, mostly just because I thought it would be something quick and easy. I’m applying for some positions doing network security which require knowledge of Palo Alto firewalls and IPsec site-to-site VPNs, though, so I may pursue either the PCNSA or SVPN exams in order to bolster my knowledge with those solutions.

    I’m also roughly halfway through an associates degree program now which has severely limited my free time that I once used to study for certifications…but that’s not a terrible problem to have either.

  • Exam Review: Cisco SISE 300-715

    Back in late 2019, I made a decision that I was going to attempt to take the Cisco IINS 210-260 and SISAS 300-208 tests prior to the “Certpocalypse” of exams retiring in late February 2020.  My thinking was two-fold:

    1. My existing CCNA Cybersecurity Operations certification would be retitled as a “Cisco Certified CyberOps Associate.”  By passing the IINS exam I would be able to retain my CCNA status within the Security domain.

    2. The new exams being released after February 2020 would consist of a core exam and one or more specialty exams.  If I passed the SISAS test prior to its expiration, I would then only need to take one test – the SCOR – to convert that result into a CCNP level certification.

    Unfortunately, spoiler alert, I slacked off on my studies and did not make the progress that I had hoped I would.  I did eventually sit for the IINS exam but failed by a matter of just under 50 points.  Close, but no cigar.

    I sat idle for two or three months and brooded over my failure.  It had broken a streak of seven successful exam attempts in a row and I was miffed.  If only I had gotten three, maybe four more questions correct…

    Eventually I got over myself.  We had Cisco learning credits due to expire at work so I invested them heavily into the new exams.  I decided that I was going to make my goal of getting the CCNP Security certification come true, and I would do it prior to my year-end review – which is in October of this year.

    I selected the SISE 300-715 exam to begin with rather than the SCOR exam.  The SISE is one of several specialty exams for the new CCNP Security certification, and the updated version of the SISAS exam I was planning to take originally.  I chose this specialty specifically because I use Cisco ISE daily at work and I thought it would be a cake walk.

    What I learned, however, is that Cisco ISE has a lot more to offer than what we use it for, and I quickly began to feel like I was in over my head.

    Score Results

    First of all, I’ll admit that I’m not necessarily proud of the score or my individual topic results, but since the Cisco Press OCG book doesn’t release until October I’m not going to look a gift horse in the mouth on this one.

    There were several topics (like Web Auth and Guest Services) which were completely alien to me on a first pass over the material.

    My score breakdown by topic:

    • Architecture and Deployment – 67%
    • Policy Enforcement – 60%
    • WebAuth and Guest Services – 44%
    • Profiler – 86%
    • BYOD – 67%
    • Endpoint Compliance – 100%
    • Network Access Device Administration – 67%

    Study Materials and Cost

    For preparation, I used the following resources:

    CCNP Security SISAS 300-208 Official Cert Guide (Cisco Press) – Cost:  $105.23
    I messed up on this one by purchasing the book as a standalone item from Amazon back in 2019, which didn’t give me access to the practice test.  I ended up buying the e-book and practice test bundle separately in 2020.  If you absolutely, positively, have to take the SISE exam prior to October 2020, then this is for you.  Otherwise…wait for the revised edition to come out.

    CPLL-SISE-V3 Implementing and Configuring Cisco Identity Services Engine (Cisco Learning Library) – Cost:  $500
    I’ve listed the retail cost here, but since I used Cisco learning credits, this resource ended up being free to me.  I’d recommend it if you can afford it – or have learning credits available for use.  It makes a good companion to the printed materials and includes practice questions which aren’t carbon copies of those found in the OCG practice test.

    CCNP Security Cisco Identity Services Engine SISE 300-715 Complete Video Course (Pearson LiveLessons) – Cost:  $399.99  $129.89
    Cisco Press was running a discount on this video series for the new exams when I purchased it, so your mileage may vary.  I try to use as many different materials sources as I can, as having the same topic explained from multiple viewpoints can often help me assimilate that knowledge better myself.  For the cost I was happy with this course – although, since I only purchased it about 30 days before my exam, I did not end up making it all the way through the course.

    Network-Node.com – Cost:  Free
    Katherine McNamara is a Cisco engineer who holds multiple CCIEs and maintains a blog at network-node.com.  She has documented step-by-step Cisco ISE configuration steps for multiple ISE versions which helped explain technical material in a way that the Cisco Learning Library and Pearson LiveLessons videos just didn’t capture as well, and made perfect write-ups to follow along with if you’re labbing.

    LabMinutes.com – Cost:  Free
    This website contains a whole suite of free videos on multiple Cisco subjects, one of which is Cisco ISE – multiple versions of it at that.  There is an option to pay for downloads but you can very easily just stream the videos you’d like on demand from their website as well.  Unfortunately, this is another resource I only found out about only shortly before my exam was scheduled, so I didn’t get to use it for its full value.  If you’re just beginning your studies for the SISE exam definitely look this one up.

    Exam Fee – Cost:  $300
    I would be remiss if I didn’t include this cost.  Fairly standard as far as Cisco exams are considered.

    In Retrospect…

    I feel like the lack of a good practice test really didn’t help me much on this exam.  I did have the SISAS practice test from Cisco Press, but there are numerous differences between the SISAS and the SISE exams – namely, the SISAS is based on ISE v1.2 and SISE is based on ISE v2.4.

    There were also practice test questions included with the Cisco Learning Library Course, but I don’t feel like their difficulty was anywhere near what I encountered on the real exam.  The conceptual questions, sure, but not the specific configuration-based questions.

    Another opportunity for improvement on my part would have been labbing the principles I’m not familiar with.  I did download a trial version VM of ISE from Cisco but I had issues with the VM and had to reinstall it several times.  I never got as far as configuring profiles, guest access, or webauth portals as I intended to do, and ultimately ran out of time.  I feel like this lack of hands-on experience with configurations I have never performed is largely what contributed to my poor exam results.

    What’s Next?

    Now that I’ve passed the SISE exam – by the skin of my teeth – the only thing left to do is take on the SCOR exam.  In this case, luckily the SCOR book from Cisco Press is already available for purchase, so I shouldn’t have to try and reverse engineer the exam topics based on five year old material like I did with SISE.  There also seems like there’s a lot of carry-over in material from the IINS exam that I failed in February, which should hopefully make things easier for me before October.

    Here’s to hoping, anyway…

  • Hands-On With the Ubiquiti USG-PRO-4: Year 1

    In July of 2018, exactly a year ago, I was looking for just about any reason at all to pull the trigger on a firewall device for my home network and found myself split between the Meraki MX series, the Fortinet FortiGate line, or one of the two Ubiquiti USG options available at the time. (more…)